Rohit's struggles, Axar's dilemma and India's World Cup lessons from New Zealand

Karthik Krishnaswamy

espn|19-11-2026

Virat Kohli produced the innings of the series in the first ODI at Eden Park, a 51-ball 74 that was full of audacious drives on the up and a dazzling array of pulls. He didn't reach double figures in any of the other matches, but sometimes you can be in the form of your life and still run into challenging conditions, unplayable deliveries, or, as happened with the in-seaming Matt Henry shooter that bowled him in the fourth ODI, a combination of both.

Rohit Sharma, by contrast, struggled from start to finish. Even though he came into the series with two hundreds and a 92 in his last four ODI innings, he has not looked like the world-beater he was in this format until last year's Champions Trophy.
Is he still one of India's two best ODI openers? And do the selectors and team management still believe he is the right man for the job at next year's World Cup?

Axar: an imperfect solution to a difficult problem

India have pushed Axar Patel up the order in ODIs with a fair bit of success, but that success has typically come in Asian conditions, where spinners bowl a large chunk of the middle overs.
In New Zealand, India used him at No. 5 in three of the four ODIs, and the move only exposed his limitations.

Bounce was a major factor throughout the series, and Axar's problems against the short ball surfaced again and again. He wasn't alone in this; Shreyas Iyer had his troubles too, but the worrying part was how often Axar struggled to keep the lifting ball down, fending or steering it airily into the area behind square on the off side. He scored 21 and 46 in the last two ODIs at Mount Maunganui, but was dropped first ball in the fourth ODI and dropped twice in his first 11 balls in the fifth.
In short, Axar didn't convince as a No. 5 in these conditions, and while the pitches at the World Cup in Southern Africa may not have the seam movement of these New Zealand surfaces, some of them are likely to be just as bouncy.

Axar, however, bowled beautifully on pitches where he wasn't expected to be much of a force. He hit an impeccable length, as expected, but also used the strong winds to accentuate his drift. He consistently tested the left-handers' outside edge and had Nick Kelly stumped with a beauty in the fourth ODI — his figures of 10-0-39-2 in that game were remarkable given New Zealand scored 333.

All in all, Axar remains a valuable package, given there aren't that many players in India who possess his combination of all-round ability and experience.
India could field a plausible XI without him if Hardik Pandya is fit, but given how rarely that has happened of late, it's hard to see how Axar doesn't remain a key player going into the World Cup.