‘You deserve to lose’: Ex-England captain slams Team India and pitch after Kolkata defeat

Sandy Verma

Tezzbuzz|17-11-2025

NEW DELHI: India suffered a heavy blow in Kolkata as South Africa ended a 15-year wait for a Test win on Indian soil, defeating the hosts by 30 runs. The loss sparked intense criticism from fans and cricket experts, who questioned both the pitch conditions and the Indian batting lineup’s ability to handle spin.

Vaughan’s lashes on Eden Gardens surface

Former England captain Michael Vaughan did not hold back on social media. He wrote, “Prepare a pitch like that and you deserve to lose against the World Test champs …. brilliant win by SA …. #INDvSA.”

The post highlighting the extreme challenge it posed for the Indian batters and praising South Africa’s superior performance on a difficult wicket.

Indian batting struggles under scrutiny

India’s batsmen struggled to build partnerships, with the team eventually collapsing under pressure. The home side’s inability to negotiate spin consistently became evident, inviting further debate about the team’s adaptability on turning tracks. Experts noted that the Eden Gardens surface demanded careful footwork and patience, areas where India fell short.

On the third day, South Africa’s Simon Harmer ripped through the Indian batting order, leaving the hosts reeling. Amidst the collapse, Temba Bavuma stood out as the lone savior, crafting a gritty unbeaten half-century. His 55-run innings laid the foundation for South Africa’s competitiveness and ultimately helped seal a memorable victory.