Expectations were sky-high from Gautam Gambhir when BCCI appointed him as India head coach in July 2024. Known for his aggressive mindset and fierce will to win, Gambhir was seen as someone who could usher Team India into a new era of dominance.

However, as months passed, the narrative began to shift. Instead of consistent success, conversations increasingly revolved around defeats, shattered records, and disappointing performances.

Despite the criticism, Gambhir's tenure has not been devoid of success. India did clinch major trophies during this period, achievements that cannot be overlooked.

Matches played: 27, Matches won: 23

Matches lost: 3, No result: 1

Win percentage: 85.18%

Matches played: 20, Matches won: 12

Matches lost: 7, Matches tied: 1

Win percentage: 60.00%

Matches played: 16, Matches won: 11

Matches lost: 3, No result: 2

Win percentage: 68.75%

Test cricket takes major hit

India's long-standing reputation as an unbeatable force at home in Test cricket suffered a serious blow under Gautam Gambhir's leadership. The once-formidable fortress began to crumble, with the team registering several unwanted records.

Matches played: 19, Matches won: 7

Matches lost: 10, Matches drawn: 2

Win percentage: 36.84%

Unwanted records in Test cricket

India lost a home Test series to New Zealand for the first time since 1988

First home Test series defeat since 2012

In November 2024, India were whitewashed in a home Test series for the first time since 2000

Lowest ever home Test score - 46 runs (October 2024)

In November 2025, India suffered their biggest Test defeat in terms of runs

Failed to qualify for the World Test Championship final for the first time

Lost the Border-Gavaskar Trophy for the first time since 2015

These numbers underline how significantly India’s grip on Test cricket weakened during this phase.

ODI troubles add to concerns

The struggles extended to the ODI format as well. India lost the third ODI against New Zealand in Indore on Sunday, January 18, resulting in a 1-2 series defeat.

It marked the first time New Zealand won an ODI series on Indian soil, further denting India’s dominance at home.

Lost the Border-Gavaskar Trophy for the first time since 2015

These numbers underline how significantly India’s grip on Test cricket weakened during this phase.

ODI troubles add to concerns

The struggles extended to the ODI format as well. India lost the third ODI against New Zealand in Indore on Sunday, January 18, resulting in a 1-2 series defeat.

It marked the first time New Zealand won an ODI series on Indian soil, further denting India’s dominance at home.